Just a week into nominations for the Cringely (NOT in Silicon Valley) Startup Tour we have 200 companies signed up to vie for the 24 positions. My hope to reach 600 in eight weeks, then, is very possible if I keep up the pressure and perhaps define the rules a little better. That’s what this column is for.
Non-U. S. companies are out. We’ve had a few Canadian companies enquire and one even claimed to be from Vancouver, WA instead of Vancouver, BC. No, that won’t do. This is a U. S. competition, but that doesn’t mean the next season won’t be international. In fact I can almost guarantee it will be.
Remember this is for TV as well as for the web so I might use a Canadian company or two as examples of how things are different for startups than in the U. S. but the 24 finalists will all be companies whose intergalactic headquarters are in the U. S.
While foreign startups are out of the running this time, companies based in Silicon Valley and other tech hotbeds definite are not disqualified. I know this seems to go against the spirit of the competition, but I want the best startups I can find and if a few of those are San Jose or Boston that’s okay. My kids have never been to Boston.
Next, I’m sorry you don’t like the web site, but pouting doesn’t help, either, and it’s simply not attractive. We’re making changes to improve the site daily so let’s concentrate more on the potential of this competition and less on your personal disdain for certain kinds of javascript.
No multiple submissions! Before you nominate a company look to see if it is already there. And submitting in multiple categories won’t help, either, so stop it.
Now about those categories, I came up with the original six but there have been suggestions that maybe I’m being too strict, that perhaps there should be an education category and possibly one for finance. I am open to these changes, but only if there is real demand, so speak up in the comments section for this post.
Finally, there are some companies that want to nominate themselves but they are still in stealth mode and feel they dare not. Here’s what I suggest for you guys. if you believe your company is something really special and if you are fairly confident that you will be out of stealth mode six months from now (next September-October when the TV series starts to air) then contact me directly at bob@cringely.com and maybe we can still do something together.
I am willing to sign NDAs and will keep your grubby secrets until next fall. But you have to understand that each company I visit costs me about $20,000, so if you are going to change your mind about publicity next fall then let’s just forget it.
There’s always another startup.
I have a great idea for series 2:
Make it an international tour and do it in a plane that you built at home in 30 days! The ultimate Cringely show.
“Vancouver is a city on the north bank of the Columbia River in the U.S. state of Washington and the county seat of Clark County.” – Wikipedia entry on Vancouver, Washington
🙁
I know that. I made most of my PBS shows for Oregon Public Broadcasting remember? Vancouver, WA is just across the Columbia River.
The problem in this case is that when I went to the website of the nominated company it said Vancouver BRITISH COLUMBIA. Weasels.
Then maybe you should have stated at the get go that this competition is US only so that the company didn’t waste it’s time registering. Just having a drop-down with US states counts.
As a Canadian I am constantly frustrated with US-centric websites (and webmasters) that don’t seem to consider that their websites cross the border (WORLD-wide-web) when I’m trying to register for things or access content only to find that it’s available in the US only.
Meant to say.
“Just having a drop-down with US states DOESN’T count.”
I’m constantly frustrated by my fellow Canadians who seem to forget that the U.S. is a foreign country to us and we’re foreigners to Americans. When visiting a U.S.-based website, your default thinking should be that it is only open to the U.S. unless otherwise stated. If you were from Iraq or Germany or Brazil would you have made the same post? Would you have expected to be able to enter a company in this contest from there? I don’t think it would be that surprising to hear that they wouldn’t. Canada need not be treated differently every time just because we’re neighbours.
@Cory
I see. So it is my fault then because I did not do the proper research to see what country the website is based in? Surely the webmaster should assume that only visitors from their country would be visiting their website.
My bad. Thanks for the clarification.
Actually, Mike’s right. Living in Europe, I’ve learned to assume a US-only attitude of US sites that deal with online contests and shopping.
Sometimes, when shopping is involved, the site may very well deal with other countries too, but for contests in 99 cases out of 100 it’s US-only.
@Mike: yeah, everybody knows Cringely is US-based. And so is PBS. And the Kauffman foundation.
It does make sense to see if you qualify before entering a contest.
I think an Education and Finance section are good ideas.
I keep mentioning green technology. But Bob keeps ignoring me.
1 on more categories. My company deals with accounting and the IT category is too limiting, we’re simply not an IT company. I love the idea of making education and finance categories.
I’d also vote for an education category. IT is definitely too broad a net to hold all the diversity that’s in there right now, and just wait til there’s 370 entries in that one category.
Education!!
I, too, am voting for an education category.
I nominated my website, Clickademics.com, in the entertainment category, though few students would think that watching chemistry video lessons is very entertaining.
Thanks for the contest.
How about a Sports category? I’m sure there are lots of people out there making high end mountain bike bits or equipment for hiking or applying technology to training athletes.
See 333 Skis website . . .
Thanks for doing this. We are excited about the opportunity.
Education – Yes!…. Finance – OK.
In the next series, do include Canada. Great place with great people (no I’m not Canadian but have seen alot of it).
How about an ‘All Others’ category?
Just for the hell of it, do your next show on “shutdowns” – creative destruction and all that – companies that are dinosaurs, that should be going extinct. They won’t be inviting you, so there’s no danger of bias or self promotion. I remember seeing a GE ad for vacuum tubes that disparaged the transistor . . . stuff like that. Should be fun.
p.s. The oil industry is a good place to start.
I guess what I’m trying to say is, we’re coming off a boom cycle and into a bust cycle. Boom or bust, there is never a shortage of great, innovative startups. But what happens at the peak of the boom is they get choked by bad, dysfunctional companies. Anyone who gardens can attest that a neglected garden goes bad, not from a shortage of desirable plants, but from a surfeit of undesirable plants – weeds – that choke them off. Good companies get starved of the resources they need to grow by having to compete with a horde of bad companies. They get starved of capital, their message gets lost, their potential customers are wary of being burned again.
To use a completely different analogy, boost transmission power and signal to noise ratio degrades. Eventually communication becomes impossible: too little signal, too much noise.
So what we need to do most to get the next upswing going, is to show the dinosaurs the exit. Ok, big oil was a no brainer IMHO. What else? How about the hyper-trophic military complex? Finance? I suspect the signal to noise ration is getting pretty poor in that sector . . . let’s have some CREATIVE DESTRUCTION !
Great advice, here we learn about very well features. I should just give up and take lessons from you 🙂
It will help to check on the existing listing of companies if the list was was in alphabetical order.
I recommend that Health Care, Web 2.0, and Social Media categories be established.
I nth Education and Finance categories as well.
Also, thanks Bob for making it clear your site is a no-whining/no-assholes zone. Word.
what an amazing post that I have ever come through. It gives the information that I was really searching for the past week and I am really satisfied with this post. Need more like this. Thank you.
Don
I m strongly happy after I ve readed your post , thank you and please write some more for us!
Well , i m amazed by this ladyboy post , can you write more ? Thank you anyway!
Really unbelivable nice , thank you so much for this fantastic post about sexy shemales … post more I bookmarked you
I just think you have wrote an hot piece of post , thank you and … bookmarked!
Fantastic posy dude! I loved to read it and I promise I will bookmark your blog , well done!
Fantastic posy dude! I loved to read it and I promise I will bookmark your blog , well done!
I will bookmark your internet site right now! Too sweet to be real what you wrote! Post more ok?
You have really made an amazing post about this topic, just post more and many thanks for everything!
Hi just thought i would certainly tell you one thing.. It is twice today i have landed on the blog within the last 2 days looking for totally unrelated things. Odd or what?
Hi, should say amazing blog you have, i stumbled across it in Yahoo. Does you get much visitors?
I’ve been into blogging for quite some time and this is definitely a effective and well written post. You should definitely check my personal list of wholesalers and suppliers exclusive to eBay and Amazon that I have collected over the years I’ve worked on eBay.
Anyways, good luck on your blog, and feel free to check out : List Of Suppliers
Thanks so much!
All the best,
Dino Vedo
Hi; Nice post for me. Your post has valuable infos. I wish to has good posts like yours in my website. How do you write these posts?
video izlemenin keyfi videocok.com ile çıkar.
Only this live tranny can make me satisfied ! I d appreciate you to post additional! Please nad I ve bookmarked you!
good thanks o/
good (article|information) thanks
I want to thank the blogger very considerably not only for this submit but also for his all earlier work. I found thesimpleyoga.com to be drastically intriguing. I will be coming again to thesimpleyoga.com for more info
Lucky i discovered , this amazing site, Another good site is Dbolwill make sure to bookmark it so i can come to frequently.
household insurance quotes
Lucky i discovered , this amazing site, Another good site is Dbolwill make sure to bookmark it so i can come to frequently.
clever posting! I think that helps me nicely. Answers a few doubts for me. Many thanks
Insightful story:) Will require a bit of time to absorb the stuff=)
discovered , this amazing site, Another good site is Dbolwill make sure to bookmark thank you
Magic Mont Blanc Ballpoint Pen X is a precision writing instrument that features a hard-anodized aerospace-grade aluminum body with a stainless steel clip/ tip. The makes a wonderful business gift that will be appreciated and cherished.
I just love to read new topics from you blog
A lot of thanks for all of the effort on this web page.