Geniuses can be found on every street corner in Silicon Valley, but visionaries are much less common. Geniuses are good at completing tasks while visionaries are the first to recognize tasks that need completion. And of all the visionaries none were greater or had a longer range view than Doug Engelbart, who died last night at age 88.
To most people who recognize his name Doug Engelbart was the inventor of the computer mouse but he was much, much more than that. In addition to the mouse and the accompanying chord keyboard, Doug invented computer time sharing, network computing, graphical computing, the graphical user interface and (with apologies to Ted Nelson) hypertext links. And he invented all these things — if by inventing we mean envisioning how they would work and work together to create the computing environments we know today — while driving to work one day in 1950.
Doug had a vision of modern computing back in the day when many computers were still mechanical and
user interfaces did not even exist. He saw in a flash not only the way we do things today but also the long list of tasks that had to be completed to get from there to here. Now that’s vision.
Doug recognized immediately that to even describe his vision to computer scientists of the time would be to invite ridicule. He laid it all out for a colleague once and was advised to keep the whole idea under his hat, it was so crazy.
So Doug spent decades in the trenches building devices and writing software he knew to be already obsolete. But that’s what you do when you have a wife and young daughters and want to get to that point in life where you can actually realize the dream.
When that finally happened in the late 1960s at the Stanford Research Institute, Doug had both his most sublime moment of public recognition and his greatest disappointment. The recognition came in December, 1968 in a live 90-minute demonstration at the Joint Computer Conference held that year in San Francisco. Here is a link to that demo.
The impact of this mother of all demos can’t be over-estimated. Engelbart and his team showed graphical and networked computing, the mouse, screen icons, dynamically linked files and hypertext to an audience of 1000 computer scientists who until that morning thought computing meant punched cards. The result of six years of work, the demo was equivalent to dropping-in on a model rocketry meeting and bringing with you a prototype warp drive. The world of computing was stunned.
But then nothing happened.
Doug got accolades, but he expected research contracts and those didn’t immediately appear. He was not only still too far ahead of his time, he naively failed to realize that vested powers in the research community would keep money flowing toward now obsolete research. When the research really got going again much of it was not at SRI but at XEROX PARC, where many of Doug’s team members landed in the early 1970s.
If Apple stole technology from XEROX, then XEROX in turn stole from Doug and SRI.
Being a visionary takes both patience and determination and Doug made it clear he thought the world needed much more from him than just the mouse. He was a huge proponent of the chord keyboard, for example. And when the personal computer took off Doug didn’t cheer because he thought the power of a timesharing minicomputer was required. And he was right, because today’s PC has the power of a timesharing minicomputer. Doug was delighted when he realized that his Augment system could run faster on a local PC emulator than on the Big Iron at SRI.
I met Doug Engelbart in the late 1970s, introduced by my friend Kirk, who worked in Doug’s lab. We spent a day with Doug for Triumph of the Nerds in 1995. I did a noteworthy NerdTV interview with Doug back in 2005. And just last year for Computer History Day Mary Alyce and I took our boys to Doug’s house for a very pleasant afternoon. There has never been a nicer man, at least to me.
I once asked Doug what he’d want if he could have anything. “I’d like to be younger,” he said. “When I was younger I could get so much more done. But I wouldn’t want to be any less than 50. That would be ideal.”
The visionaries who created a highway for us where there was no foot path. May the example of their labour inspire us on to greater heights. Now @ 50+, he makes me feel young all over again!
Bob, Thank you very much for writing this.
This is the kind of article that identifies you the best.
Accidental Empires: the Saga Never Ends !
Thank you.
We lost a true visionary in the field of computer science. It is sad to see him go and yet he accomplished so much in his life. Rest in peace Doug, you earned it. He won’t be forgotten nor will his contributions.
Funny, I just heard an interview with E.O. Wilson (Biologist and s%#t disturber) on NPR’s Science Friday, and he said geniuses were bad at doing tasks, they were good and figuring out what needs to be done, but usually get bored doing what needs to be done.
Maybe so. In the past I’ve compared hippies and nerds and what you’ve described covers hippies beautifully. I think the key here is the distinction between regular old geniuses and visionaries who see the BIG PICTURE where others can’t.
Yo Bob! That was a “low blow”! I’m a hippie and probably not a genius, yet I have been know to have ideas and to get things done 😉 So maybe that doesn’t prove anything, sigh…
Great piece – indeed the man was a visinoary with a great view! His demos are incredible! Thanks again for sharing all this with us!
Bob
Yea, that’s my excuse also. But for some strange reason no one seems to recognize me for the genius I am. Perhaps I’ll have to actually DO something to prove it.
“usually get bored doing what needs to be done.” Very true . . .
I remember Doug’s name from way back, but like so many, just thought “mouse”. Whilst this always impressed me immensely, it saddens me to realize only now, just how far ahead he really was. I just watched his 1968 “Mother of all Demos” video and it is utterly staggering. What a fantastic mind, I hope we can all continue to learn, and be influenced by him. – Ian Thompson-Yates, Montrose, AL.
I came into computing through the rusty back door – the SAGE system and NORAD. When I was in the USAF in the early 1970’s, I kept hearing rumors about this amazing demo that was practically Science Fiction it was so advanced. In the 80’s I worked for one of the industry computing giants and still I would hear of “the demo” in hushed and reverent tones. When I finally saw the video in the early 2000’s I was simply blown away. Watching him demonstrate the various pieces of our shared future from 30+ years in the past truly moved me. A visionary, certainly. An evangelist, absolutely. A giant has passed.
Perfect example of a paradigm shift and how people both can’t initially appreciate the benefits and also actively work to suppress it – then years later everyone characterises it as having been just an invention and some sort of obvious next step.
Having powerful tools to make it easier to do complicated tasks is great. Having the wisdom to know which tasks are worth doing is even greater. Being able to circumvent those powerful special interests who want to control our government and rule our lives for their own selfish and perverted reasons is the absolute best.
Its 1968 and high school… A year away from learning assembly language/fortran/cobal with a stack of “punch cards” as input !
Simply amazing demo. Thanks, great article
A hyperlink to the Triumph of the Nerds interview would be great along with the Nerd TV interview.
Do you still have access to all that like the lost Steve Jobs interview or does PBS control it all?
Go to http://www.beyondrealtime.com to see a post I did on someone very special, someone in the league of a Jobs, Einstein and Tesla. I would have loved to have known him. People like this are gems to the max.
“He saw in a flash not only the way we do things today…”
Today? I think 2026 is more likely, if we are lucky. There is a video on Youtube which uses audio from parts of The Demo while we see the screen of someone using a modern computer. Not only do they skip lots of important parts that can’t be easily replicated, the parts that are shown often capture just the look of The Demo without the substance. Copying a line and then pasting it twice in completely unstructured text isn’t the same thing Doug was doing with his outline.
Got a link to that?
Here is the 4 minute Youtube video with the audio from the Demo and modern software:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnwppf6hLiA&feature=youtu.be
Most of the ideas that are described as inventions really just involve bolting existing ideas or technologies together. They don’t really do anything new, they just perform old tasks in different situations.
Douglas Engelbart’s vision of the modern computer, on the other hand, invoved creating tools that used computers in a completely new way. It’s possibly the only real invention in the past half century, if not far longer. Except maybe for Amazon’s one click patent 🙂
Even in 1967 Doug and the USPO agreed that a mouse was a far better way to navigate a computer than using a finger. Still true today. 🙂
Doug Engelbart was indeed a genius and a visionary who proposed and prototyped many innovations that we depend on today. However, “time sharing computing” was not one of them. My definition here is the simultaneous sharing of a computer by several users at remote locations such that each appears to have control of the machine. Several proposals and descriptions were published in the mid-1950’s and demos built by 1960. I think Kemeny at Dartmouth with support from GE built the first commercially viable system in about 1964-65 using teletypes as remote terminals and BASIC as a “universal” interactive programming language.
Arguments like this one will probably never be resolved. All I can say is that probably the most commercially successful offshoot of Doug’s work at SRI was Tymshare, the first computer timesharing company. Also I knew John Kemeny and worked with him in 1979 and he didn’t see timesharing as his invention: we discussed it at that time.
Here’s another link to the complete (un-segmented) demo, pretty good quality video, on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY … what a brilliant guy, he will be missed … R.I.P Doug.
why “with apologies to Ted Nelson” ??
Ted Nelson and Douglas E. was very close friends, later.
but if you really want to dig deeper, even Vannevar Bush could thanks to Paul Otlet!! (but pretty sure that Vannevar B. never heard for Paul Otlet’s “Palais Mondial”)
so please Cringely, stick to the time-line and, more important: to evolution of idea!
(something that Ted’s Xanadu Space will provide! ;))
Doug and Ted came to hypertext at about the same time though from different directions. It’s hard to say exactly who got there first, though Ted’s effort, as I recall, began a bit later, around 1960. But I can’t say who the winner was so I felt it was important to acknowledge Ted while honoring Doug, that’s all. Just trying to be polite since I was friends with both men.
What Up? Yoda in da house 🙂
I can’t decide if I’m horrified or impressed that on a visit Doug frickin Engelbart you chose to wear a Batman sweatshirt.
Website Problem Back:
This article and the 9 earlier articles have a decreasing comment count today vs. yesterday:
Today: 027 271 080 008 014 014 040 062 054 092
Yesterday: 035 276 081 008 014 014 042 062 054 092
Another problem: this post on 7/9/13 is listed before the post on 7/7/13
Great piece – indeed the man was a visinoary with a great view! His demos are incredible! Thanks again for sharing all this with us!