There is no good aspect to cyber bullying, but maybe there’s a little light to be found in the underlying idea that people interact differently online than they do in person. That’s not all bad if it gives a voice — an academic voice — to students who might otherwise remain silent in class. This is certainly the experience of Democrasoft, a startup I have written about before that seems to have stumbled on a whole new class of software for education.
Democrasoft’s Collaborize product began as a way for communities to discuss issues online with the idea that the core groups would be cities or local governments. But the Santa Rosa, CA-based company found some of its earliest adopters were teachers — a group the company had never even considered. More than 6600 teachers are presently using Collaborize, which is still a very small percentage of American classrooms. But the adoption growth rate is a very viral 30+ percent per month, according to Democrasoft CEO Richard Lang, so this application is going to be significant.
A lot has changed about Collaborize since I last wrote about it. The business model for education is now free, for example, and there is a custom version, Collaborize Classroom, just for schools — the company’s largest present market.
The idea behind Collaborize is simple. It is a structured conversation. Any participant can pose a question for discussion, eliciting responses from the group or taking a poll. You can look at it as a quiz or a test but grading doesn’t have to be a part of what’s essentially an online Socratic dialog.
Yes, you can do this with a wiki, Mr. Smartypants, but the significant point here is that people generally don’t do this with wikis. Collaborize is more structured than a wiki and requires little customization.
One of the most important aspects of this tool, according to the teachers who like it, is that it has a social leveling function that brings students into the online conversation who might say little or nothing in the classroom. This is good.
What’s changed most recently with the product, though, is the addition of some social networking functions and especially the development of a library of discussions available to anyone.
Here’s the deal with the library. Some teachers are better than others at designing discussions. These can include video and audio clips to spur discussion and each becomes a little lesson in its own right, providing information, eliciting responses, and even measuring comprehension all at the same time. That’s powerful. But if you are a teacher who is intimidated by the whole question design process, why not use some other teacher’s discussions, either in their entirety or as the basis for your own derivative work?
The library already contains thousands of discussions in nearly every subject area.
Social networking provides both the door to this library and something even more important — peer review. Maybe a discussion could be improved or maybe it is just plain misguided: responses from other teachers will provide that context. If a discussion from the library gets a lot of positive responses from teachers whose opinions you respect that makes the discussion more valuable.
I think this is great, especially because we Cringelys are embarking now on our own experiment in home schooling, where I’ll be borrowing shamelessly from Collaborize Classroom (my only connection with the company, by the way).
The more tools I have on my belt the better I feel.
This is an important idea since it fits with how people learn. We know that the two key elements in learning are social and affect. When people are in a social situation what they experience and share has a greater affect then learning on their own. These social situation helps learners reflect and put what they are reflecting on into action.
Social media (eg Twitter, FB, etc.) are just tactics. What we miss in our rush to SM is the need for a strategy. I believe the SM can best serve a learning strategy. It seems Colaborize has discovered this.
One more point, this could be an excellent tool for patient physician learning. NOT practicing medicine but a platform to help improve patient knowledge through a trusted source your physician.
Seriously. How much did they pay you for this puff piece?
Tell me, is this the site where you post the annual naked pictures of your children?
What? Are you a child? I hope so! Stay away from your parent’s computer, OK?
4th, booya!
democrasoft and collaborizer will never merit the digital ink spent on them already.
Hey Seriously Bob,
You are seriously a asshole whom my seriously capable self would like to give a serious ass kickin to. Don’t seriously classless jerks like yourself ever give a serious thought that other serious people that regularly read this blog don’t give a serious crap what folks like your serious self have to say. Go somewhere else.
Yawn..
Either you deserve kudos for a reasonable obscure sarcastic posting, or a Darwin award. I really can’t decide..
Hey Larz,
I’m leaning towards the Darwin award mentioned above. Since you chose to come here and read the blog; you’re like the guy who crashes into the lake and then screams “Hey! Who put this damn lake here!”
Larz,
I think people are mis-reading your comment. I certainly did the first time.
You addressed it to “Seriously Bob” which is the moniker used by a commenter above who deserved your vitriol.
I at first thought your comment was to Bob X Cringely as obviously a few others did as well.
There is a “reply” link to direct a reply to a single post.
Since Larz didn’t use it, I was puzzled.. Was it a reply to the “Seriously Bob”, or some idiot leapfrogging off the previous posting, or an obscure form of sarcasm related to the title of this blog?
On rereading today, I tend to agree with your interpretation.
Thanks to social networks, the concept of threaded posts is getting lost. With threading, even “@” replies are completely unnecessary.
Just as there are a number of ways to skin a cat (none of which I recommend, BTW), so are there a number of ways to learn how to skin a cat.
Thanks for alerting your more-than-one-track-minded readers to this application of technology toward a topic that desperately needs to be re-invented, partially,but not totally, by smart integration of appropriate technologies.
If some person tried to skin my cat, they would be clawed something fierce.
Say Bob, are we ever going to see some of the videos from the first phase of the Cringely Startup Tour?
That would be quite an enjoyable treat.
Robert X (what does X stand for) read
‘Dibs in search of Self’ by Virginia Axlrod (?)
“The family on the hill” (?) by ?
Best thing you can do for kids is home educate them!
Frank Loyd Wright (built block houses), Enoch Powell (Latin Greek at 6 professor at 21) Mozart (composer at 6) all had home education by their mothers!
If the kids are greater than 7 yo its already too late!
I have a pet theory that make Feminism look stupid!
ONE generation of mothers teaching their kids from 1 month on would make a explosion of knowledge never seen on earth ever!!
Mothers control the future and Feminists want equality!!
HOW DUMB ARE WOMEN!
I worry about copyright ruining this idea. But it sounds great for academia (and probably other things as well).
This is a really great idea! So nice to see that teachers can now share their lesson plans and really discover what works for their students. Also seems like a nice way for students who might not otherwise participate to get involved with the conversation and get inspired to contribute. And we all know that most kids are spending a lot of time in front of their computers. Good job Democrasoft! Keep up the inspiring activities!
OK maybe I don’t get the concept. You have the kids in a classroom not interacting in real time, but asymmetrically via a web app? So there is teacher sharing going on also? I don’t see anything new that Moodle hasn’t been doing for several years. There are also lesson plan sharing sites that are not tied to a specific platform. What new stuff does Collaborize bring to the table?
DT,
I apologize for not using the direct “reply” and sparing everyone my flame to “Seriously Bob” I assure everyone that it won’t happen again…Please forgive.
Larz
Sounds good for teaching but why not what it was originally intended for – government? It seems backwards to me that we still debate anything on the House floor for all six CSPAN viewers. In my opinion, put it all online, allow public comment, and let everything go into the Google cache engine. We’d have a more honest debate because if politicians knew that what they say was being recorded and entered into Google, they might actually say something intelligent.
The neighbors kids were church going and home schooled . . . most of the time they were riding their bikes up and down the street. When they got older, they were racing their cars up and down the street. Almost got ran off the road once while walking the dog. The girls got married in their early twenties. The teenage boy has a minimum wage job. I guess hillbillies would be an ungenerous, but fair, description . . . however your mileage (with home schooling) may vary. Personally I would not do it.
Yes, there is a lot to be said for leaving teaching to the teachers. From what I’ve heard about the public schools of today, private may be the way to go. I know my parents would not have been able to teach me the wide variety of stuff I had to learn at school, not to mention the motivation to “compete” for grades.
We’re in a globalized economy, and it takes 10,000 hours of instruction and practice to be world class at anything. I’m not saying you can’t make home schooling work, but it’s a lot of work – probably more than a full time job. If you’re also a writer, or doing housework, then you may not have the time to make it work. Then the kids get a few hours (or less) classroom a day, and the rest of the time they are out playing on the street. Nothing wrong with that pe se, but it’s a competitive world.
This looks like great software, but it’s quite expensive for NPO’s – are there any open-source alternatives? 😀
Some years ago IBM (as I recall) tried anonymous typing – texting in modern language – in meetings instead of speaking; it was a leveler for people who normally were shy about speaking up.
I remember using that software when it was in beta. An interesting concept, but hardly a replacement for a meeting as we tried to use it. I think it was a good idea but the implementation didn’t work very well.
BTW, what does this article have to do with the flip side of cyber bullying? Did the article go astray, or was the headline chosen for shock value?
First sentence: “there’s a little light to be found in the underlying idea that people interact differently online than they do in person.”
I may be stupid, but it seems that Collaborize, as you describe it (and I’ll add further superfluous punctuation by admitting I didn’t even go and look at it), is just like a discussion board.
Developed in collaboration between legendary music producer and artist Dr. Dre, engineers from Monster Cable and renowned industrial designer Robert Brunner. The Beats by Dr. Dre Studio headphones allow you to experience music the way the artist wants you to. These high definition headphones are precision-engineered to reveal the full sound of today’s digital music including the most sonically demanding rock.
Dr. Dre Studio headphones you not only get incredible sound, but advanced, useful function to make your listening experience the best it can be. With advanced
Why wouldn’t Sony be using PayPal as their merchant bank and gateway for credit card payments as well as PayPal payments? PayPal can handle both and our theory here is that Sony has to pay someone to do it for them now instead of being able to do it themselves.
lsil…
[…]I, Cringely » Blog Archive » The flip side of cyber bullying – Cringely on technology[…]…
beats dr dre…
[…]I, Cringely » Blog Archive » The flip side of cyber bullying – Cringely on technology[…]…
beats by dre studio superman headphones…
[…]I, Cringely » Blog Archive » The flip side of cyber bullying – Cringely on technology[…]…
can be about anything you want it…
to be.a steady communication streamdoes your company publish a newsletter? every article in that newsletter would likely make a good blog post.perhaps you have an interesting story about how your company won a certain contract. or where some of your ma…
Greetings! I’ve been following your website for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from New Caney Texas! Just wanted to tell you keep up the good job!|Greetings from California! I’m bored at work so I decided to check out your website on my iphone during lunch break.Carman Nistler[url=https://www.wirelessexterminators.com
]Carman Nistler[/url]https://www.wirelessexterminators.com
I like what you guys are up too.Priscila Hisrich[url=https://www.listlaws.com
]Priscila Hisrich[/url]https://www.listlaws.com